Sacrificing Gaza: The Great March of Zionist Hypocrisy
Date Written: 04/06/2018
Year Published: 2018
Resource Type: Article
Cx Number: CX22508
The Great March of Return is a startling, powerful expression of Palestinian identity and resistance. Thousands of Palestinians have come out, bravely and unapologetically, to say: We refuse to remain invisible. We reject any attempt to assign us to the discard pile of history. We will exercise our fundamental right to go home. They have done this unarmed, in the face of Israels use of deadly armed force against targets (children, press, medics) deliberately chosen to demonstrate the Jewish states unapologetic determination to force them back into submissive exile by any means necessary. By doing this repeatedly over the last few weeks, these incredibly brave men, women, and children have done more than decades of essays and books to strip the aura of virtue from Zionism thats befogged Western liberals eyes for 70 years.
What the Israelis have done over the past few weekskilling at least 112and wounding over 13,000people (332 with life-threatening injuries and 27 requiring amputation)is a historical crime that stands alongside the Sharpeville Massacre (69 killed), Bloody Sunday (14 killed), and the Birmingham Fire Hoses and Police Dog Repression as a defining moment in an ongoing struggle for justice and freedom. Like those events, this months slaughter may become a turning point for what John Pilger correctly calls the longest occupation and resistance in modern timesthe continuing, unfinished subjugation of the Palestinian people, which, like apartheid and Jim Crow, requires constant armed repression and at least occasional episodes of extermination.
The American government, political parties, and media, which support and make possible this crime are disgraceful, criminal accomplices. American politicians, media, and people, who feel all aglow about professing their back-in-the-day support (actual, for some; retrospectively-imagined, for most) of the Civil-Rights movement in the American South and the anti-apartheid struggle in South Africa but continue to ignore the Palestinian struggle for justice against Zionism, because saying peep one about it might cost them some discomfort, are disgraceful, cowardly hypocrites.
There is nothing new here. Israel has always understood the ghetto it created in Gaza. In 2004, Arnon Soffer, a Haifa University demographer and advisor to Ariel Sharon, said: "when 2.5 million people live in a closed-off Gaza, it's going to be a human catastrophe. The pressure at the border will be awful. So, if we want to remain alive, we will have to kill and kill and kill. All day, every day .If we dont kill, we will cease to exist." And when challenged again in 2007 about "Israel's willingness to do what he prescribes i.e., put a bullet in the head of anyone who tries to climb over the security fence," Soffer replied with a shrug:. "If we dont, we'll cease to exist."
We can point out the factual errors and concrete cruelties that all these apologias rely on.
We can point out that Hamas did not orchestrate these demonstrations, and that the thousands of Gazans who are risking their lives are not instruments. You people always looked down at us, one Gazan told Amira Hass, so its hard for you to understand that no one demonstrates in anyone elses name.
We can point out that the fence the Israelis are defending is not a border (What country are the Gazans in?), but the boundary of a ghetto, what Conservative British PM David Cameron called a giant prison camp and Israeli scholar Baruch Kimmerling called the largest concentration camp ever to exist. Its a camp that tens of thousands of Palestinians were forced into by the Zionist army. The right of those families (80% of Gazas population) to leave that confinement and go home is a basic human right and black-letter international law.
We can point out that Gazans arent just trying to cross a line in the sand, they are trying to break a siege,and that: The blockade is by definition an act of war, imposed and enforced through armed violence. Never in history have blockade and peace existed side by side. There is no difference in civil law between murdering a man by slow strangulation or killing him by a shot in the head. Those were, after all, the words of Israeli Foreign Minister Abba Eban, when he was justifying Israels attack on Egypt in 1967. And they are confirmed today by New York judge Mary McGowan Davis, who says: The blockade of Gaza has to be lifted immediately and unconditionally.
We can point out that there can be no excuse in terms of modern international law or human rights principles for Israels weeks-long calculated, unlawful (HRW) mass killing and crippling or unarmed protestors who were standing quietly, kneeling and praying, walking away, and tending to the wounded hundreds of meters from any fenceshootings carried out not in any fog of war confusion, but with precise, targeted sniper fire (which, per standard military practice, would be from two-manteams).
As the IDF bragged, in a quickly deleted tweet: Nothing was carried out uncontrolled; everything was accurate and measured, and we know where every bullet landed. Indeed, as Human Rights Watch reports, senior Israeli officialsorderedsnipers to shoot demonstrators who posed no imminent threat to life, and many demonstrators were shot hundreds of meters, and walking away, from the fence.