A. S. Neill

Alexander Sutherland Neill

Neill on his birthday
Born 17 October 1883 (1883-10-17)
Forfar, Scotland
Died 23 September 1973 (1973-09-24) (aged 89)
Aldeburgh, Suffolk, England
Occupation Educator, author
Known for founding Summerhill School, advocacy of personal freedom for children, progressive education

Alexander Sutherland Neill (17 October 1883 - 23 September 1973) was a Scottish progressive educator, author and founder of Summerhill school, which remains open and continues to follow his educational philosophy to this day. He is best known as an advocate of personal freedom for children.


[edit] Personal background

Neill was born in Forfar, the son of a schoolteacher. After acting as a pupil-teacher for his father, he studied at the University of Edinburgh and obtained an M.A. degree in 1912. In 1914 he became headmaster of the Gretna Green School in Scotland. During this period, his growing discontent could be traced in notes which he later published. In these notes, he described himself as "just enough of a Nietzschian to protest against teaching children to be meek and lowly"[1] and wrote (in A Dominie's Log) that he was "trying to form minds that will question and destroy and rebuild".

[edit] Educational philosophy

Neill believed that the happiness of the child should be the paramount consideration in decisions about the child's upbringing, and that this happiness grew from a sense of personal freedom. He felt that deprivation of this sense of freedom during childhood, and the consequent unhappiness experienced by the repressed child, was responsible for many of the psychological disorders of adulthood.

The main focus of educational interest and research at that time was the question of how best to produce obedient soldiers who would uncritically follow orders in battle,[citation needed] so Neill's ideas, which tried to help children achieve self-determination and encouraged critical thinking rather than blind obedience, were seen as backward, radical, or at best, controversial.

Many of Neill's ideas are widely accepted today, although there are still many more "traditional" thinkers within the educational establishment who regard Neill's ideas as threatening the existing social order, and therefore controversial.

In 1921 Neill founded Summerhill School to demonstrate his educational theories in practice. These included a belief that children learn better when they are not compelled to attend lessons. The school is also managed democratically, with regular meetings to determine school rules. Pupils have equal voting rights with school staff.

Neill's Summerhill School experience demonstrated that, free from the coercion of traditional schools, students tended to respond by developing self-motivation, rather than self-indulgence. Externally imposed discipline, Neill felt, actually prevented internal, self-discipline from developing. He therefore considered that children who attended Summerhill were likely to emerge with better-developed critical thinking skills and greater self-discipline than children educated in compulsion-based schools.

These tendencies were perhaps all the more remarkable considering that the children accepted by Summerhill were often from problematic backgrounds, where parental conflict or neglect had resulted in children arriving in a particularly unhappy state of mind. The therapeutic value of Summerhill's environment was demonstrated by the improvement of many children who had been rejected by conventional schools, yet flourished at Summerhill.

Strongly influenced by the contemporary work of Sigmund Freud and Wilhelm Reich, Neill was opposed to sexual repression and the imposition of the strict Victorian values of his childhood era. He stated clearly that to be anti-sex was to be anti-life. Naturally, these views made him unpopular with many establishment figures of the time.

[edit] Life at Summerhill

As headmaster of Summerhill, Neill taught classes in Algebra, Geometry and Metalworking. He often said that he admired those who were skilled craftsmen more than those whose skills were purely intellectual. Neill held that because attendance was optional, the classes themselves could be more rigorous. Students learned more quickly, and more deeply, because they were learning by choice, not compulsion.

Neill also had special "private lessons" with pupils, which included discussions of personal issues and amounted to a form of psychotherapy. He later abandoned these "PLs", finding that children who did not have PLs were still cured of delinquent behaviour; he therefore concluded that freedom was the cure, not psychotherapy.

During his teaching career he wrote dozens of books, including the "Dominie" (Scottish word for teacher) series, beginning with A Dominie's Log (1916). His most influential book was Summerhill: A Radical Approach to Child Rearing (1960) which created a storm in U.S. educational circles. His last work was his autobiography, Neill, Neill, Orange Peel! (1973) He also wrote humorous books for children, like The Last Man Alive (1939).

A. S. Neill was married twice. His first wife Lillian Richardson was an Australian, the sister of the novelist Henry Handel Richardson; his second wife Ena Wood Neill administered Summerhill school with him for many decades until their daughter, Zoe Redhead, took over the school as headmistress.

[edit] Influences on Neill's thought

Neill's biggest mentor in education was the British educator Homer Lane. Neill was also an admirer and close friend of psychoanalytical innovator Wilhelm Reich and a student of Freudian psychoanalysis, though in his autobiography he wrote that "Much of what I thought I had learned from the psychoanalysts has disappeared with time". [2]

Another major contributor to the field of Libertarian Education was Bertrand Russell whose own self-founded Beacon Hill School (England) (one of several schools bearing this name) is often compared with Summerhill. Russell was a correspondent of Neill and offered his support.

[edit] Criticisms of Neill

Many within the educational establishment felt threatened by Neill's work, and criticism of Neill was correspondingly harsh, and often inaccurate. Many published ad hominem attacks accusing Neill of various failings including naivety and unrealistic idealism, or even downright moral indifference. Neill was similarly criticized for bringing notions of Freudian repression into an educational setting.

Such critics often focused on what they (falsely) claimed to be the laxness of sexual morality at Summerhill.[citation needed]

[edit] Neill's educational legacy

Neill's notions of freedom and education, considered controversial in their time, influenced many of the progressive educators who came after him.

Modern advocates, such as John Taylor Gatto, John Holt and many others in the unschooling movement, democratic school movement, free school movement and homeschooling movements, have taken Neill's ideas further and updated them, providing energetic and radical critiques of the compulsion-based schooling which is still prevalent in most countries.

Due to the continuing international corporate demand for employees who can think critically and be self-motivated, as well as to the growing demand from parents for a system of education which reflects their ambitions for their children, compulsion-based systems in many countries[citation needed] are now gradually being reformed along much the same lines that Neill recommended.

Summerhill School, which Neill founded, has recently (2007) been accepted by the UK educational establishment, in particular OFSTED, as providing a good quality of academic education for children. Summerhill has also been recognised by the United Nations for its exceptionally good treatment of children.

"The convention of the Rights of the Child makes particular reference to children's rights to participate in decisions affecting them and Summerhill, through its very approach to education, embodies this right in a way that surpasses expectation." - Paulo David, Secretary, UN Committee on the Rights of the Child

[edit] Works

  • A Dominie–s Log (1916)
  • A Dominie Dismissed (1916)
  • Booming of Bunkie (1919)
  • Carroty Broon (1920)
  • A Dominie in Doubt (1920)
  • A Dominie Abroad (1922)
  • A Dominie–s Five (1924)
  • The Problem Child (1926)
  • The Problem Parent (1932)
  • Is Scotland Educated? (1936)
  • That Dreadful School (1937)
  • The Last Man Alive (1938)
  • The Problem Teacher (1939)
  • Hearts Not Heads in the School (1945)
  • The Problem Family (1949)
  • The Free Child (1953)
  • Summerhill: A Radical Approach to Child Rearing (Preface by Erich Fromm) (1960)
  • Freedom, Not License! (1966)
  • Talking of Summerhill (1967)
  • Children's Rights: Toward the Liberation of the Child (with Leila Berg, Paul Adams, Nan Berger, Michael Duane, and Robert Ollendorff) (1971)
  • Neill, Neill, Orange Peel! (1972)

[edit] Published Correspondence

  • Record of a friendship: the correspondence between Wilhelm Reich and A. S. Neill, 1936-1957 (1982)
  • All the Best, Neill: Letters from Summerhill (1984)

[edit] Portrait bust of A.S. Neill

A.S. Neill sat for sculptor Alan Thornhill for a portrait[3] in clay. The correspondence file relating to the A.S. Neill portrait sculpture is held in the archive[4] of the Henry Moore Foundation's Henry Moore Institute in Leeds and the terracotta remains in the collection of the artist. Bronzes are in the public collections of The College of Orgonomy[5], New York and the Scottish National Portrait Gallery, Edinburgh (collection reference PG2204).

[edit] References

  1. ^ Neill, A.S. (1915). A Dominie's Log. READ BOOKS, 2007 Page 66. ISBN 1406763535, 9781406763539
  2. ^ Neill, A.S. (1973). Neill! Neill! Orange Peel!. Weidenfeld and Nicolson. pp. 163. ISBN 0-297-76554X. 
  3. ^ portrait head of A.S.Neill image of sculpture
  4. ^ http://www.henry-moore-fdn.co.uk/matrix_engine/content.php?page_id=584 HMI Archive
  5. ^ The American College of Orgonomy

[edit] External links

Related topics in the Connexions Subject Index

Alternatives  –  Left History  –  Libraries & Archives  –  Social Change  – 

This article is based on one or more articles in Wikipedia, with modifications and additional content contributed by Connexions editors. This article, and any information from Wikipedia, is covered by a Creative Commons Attribution-Sharealike 3.0 Unported License (CC-BY-SA) and the GNU Free Documentation License (GFDL).

We welcome your help in improving and expanding the content of Connexipedia articles, and in correcting errors. Connexipedia is not a wiki: please contact Connexions by email if you wish to contribute. We are also looking for contributors interested in writing articles on topics, persons, events and organizations related to social justice and the history of social change movements.

For more information contact Connexions