Marc Lamont Hill's Detractors are the True Anti-Semites
Publisher: Counter Punch
Date Written: 17/12/2018
Year Published: 2018
Resource Type: Article
Cx Number: CX23190
Temple University's administration announced the unsurprising news that it has found no grounds to punish or investigate Professor Marc Lamont Hill for his speech on the occasion of the International Day of Solidarity with the Palestinian People. Yet, the university's Board of Trustees felt compelled, nonetheless, to issue a statement further maligning Dr Hill, albeit indirectly this time.
Remarkably, the Boards statement implicitly acknowledges there was nothing inherently offensive in Dr Hill's speech. Rather, the universitys objection lies in the way "many regard[ed]" it and how it was "widely perceived" or "broadly criticized." In essence, the university was unable to reasonably rebuke what was ultimately a call for justice and freedom for the Palestinian people, the colonized indigenous nation that has continuously inhabited the land between the River Jordan and Mediterranean Sea for millennia. It is therefore stunning and unprecedented that a university would hold its professor responsible not for his words, but for the ways in which others interpret them.
It is also worth noting that no such statement was issued by the Board of Trustees following the exposure of Temple journalism professor Francesca Viola, who admitted to posting conspiracy theories against Muslims and immigrants. Among other things, her anonymous account posted the word "scum" under a photo of Muslims praying and called to "get rid of them."