www.newsandletters.org












Black/Red View by John Alan
May 2001


Race and the census

The 2000 census created a great deal of discussion about the United States as a nation composed of diverse races and ethnic peoples. Some of the new celebrated facts are, for example, that in California, the largest state in the Union, Latinos are the largest ethnic group; African Americans are moving into suburbs and seven million of them have identified themselves as "bi-racial" people.

Such statistical analysis of the American society as multiethnic, implying that it is moving naturally and peacefully toward absolute social integration, is both false and an abstraction.

The mere numbers of the 2000 census say nothing about the antagonistic social divisions of race and class in American society. The Cincinnati revolt against the unconscionable killings of African- American youths by police officers has once again challenged the concept that there has been any radical shrinking of the Black-white divide. In other words, racial and ethnic diversity, by itself, can still be full of racism.

Hector St. Jean Crevecoeur, a Frenchman who lived in America in 1782 when racial diversity was very obvious, posed the famous question: "What then is the American, the new man?" He answered: "a mixture of English, Scotch, Irish, French, Dutch, German and Swede... He is either a European or a descendant of a European." Crevecoeur wrote this racist observation when African slaves were one-fifth of the population.

John Hope Franklin, the African-American historian, in his book RACE AND HISTORY considered the ethnic composition of the U.S. as "one of the salient features" of American civilization. If we closely examine American civilization, we find that the actual origin of that "salient feature" is rooted in slave labor and not in its ideological concept of freedom and diversity. The truth is: there could hardly have been a successful development of capitalism in America without African slave labor. There was no other available abundant source of labor power to cultivate the sugar, rice, tobacco and cotton. Thus, American capitalism, at that moment in its history, grafted the barbarism of slave labor onto the production of commodities for the world market which essentially made American slave masters the new capitalists.

Moreover, American capitalism did not end its exploitation of Black labor in the post Civil War era. It was inherently driven to accumulate an unprecedented amount of capital and to create the technology to accomplish that accumulation. Therefore, the American 19th-century industrial revolution and economic expansion to the Pacific coast during the post Civil War period opened the door for working class immigrants from Europe and China to come to America to build railroads, bridges, to work in the factories, the mines and the mills.

This "uprooting" of European and Asian labor from their original homes began in the latter decades of the 19th century and became a torrent by the first decade of the 20th century when upwards of 1.4 million immigrants came to America each year. This is one of the reasons why America appears today as a nation of diverse races and ethnic peoples.

We should note that the "diversity," as it is present in the 2000 census, is simply a reflection of capitalism's exploitation of labor and has nothing to do with the ideal of a human unity in diversity. American diversity emerged out of and continues to contain contradictions and strife. For example, the Mexican laborer is only welcome in California as long as she is working hard in the fields of the growers, but if she gets sick or seeks to go on relief, the political cry becomes, send her back across the border.

The African-American people have been around on the North American continent since the first Europeans colonized it. Then as now, the socialization of labor is structured according to the needs of American capital, which means new immigrant labor without any rights and the unleashing of the criminal (in)justice system against the rebellious African-American population. There can be a new beginning in the very meaning of diversity when the different groups find a commonalty in their opposition to the inhuman capitalist accumulation.



subscribe to news and letters newspaper. 10 issues per year delivered to you for $5.00/year.

Home l News & Letters Newspaper l Back issues l News and Letters Committees l Dialogues l Raya Dunayevskaya l Contact us l Search

Subscribe to News & Letters

Published by News and Letters Committees
Designed and maintained by  Internet Horizons