|
| |
Black-Red View by John Alan
March 2001
Hegel and Black history
After giving a talk recently on "Hegel, Black History and the Idea of
Freedom" in the San Francisco Bay Area, a new article on this subject was
brought to my attention: "Hegel and Haiti" (CRITICAL INQUIRY, Summer 2000)
by Susan Buck-Morss. My talk took off from how Hegel's master/slave
relationship, as the starting point for his dialectic of self-consciousness
and freedom in his PHENOMENOLOGY OF SPIRIT, has been central to Black
liberation theorists from W.E.B. DuBois to Frantz Fanon.
Not only did Hegel impact Black liberation theorists but, as Buck-Morss
shows, there is compelling evidence, ignored in the world of Hegel
scholarship, that the Black masses in the Haitian Revolution of 1803 were
the source for Hegel's famous narrative on the master/slave relation in the
PHENOMENOLOGY.
Buck-Morss shows that though the major figures of the European
Enlightenment proclaimed a new concept of liberty as the opposite of
slavery, they were nearly blind to the horrors of actually existing slavery
which was the foundation for the accumulation of wealth in the new world
trading system. She writes: "A glaring discrepancy between thought and
practice marked the period of transformation of global capitalism from its
mercantile to its protoindustrial form" (p. 821).
"The Haitian Revolution," she shows, "was the crucible, the trial by fire
for the ideals of the French Enlightenment. And every European who was part
of the bourgeois reading public knew it" (p. 837). Yet the prevailing
intellectual histories silence that reality. In the early 19th century the
German journal MINERVA, edited by Johann Wilhelm von Archenholz, reported
extensively on events in Haiti in the context of the unfolding of the
ideals of the French Revolution. MINERVA was very influential among German
intellectuals, including Hegel, who referred to reading MINERVA in his
letters.
Buck-Morss points to the way Hegel changed his theory of mutual
recognition, in the period before the PHENOMENOLOGY (1806) took form, from
one founded on customs and ethical life in the community to one based on a
struggle to the death, culminating in a fight for full social selfhood and
freedom in the master/slave dialectic. Buck-Morss takes to task the whole
world of Hegel scholarship who are at a loss to adequately account for this
dramatic development.
Some, like Otto Pöggeler, say it emerged in Hegel as a "totally 'abstract'
example" (p. 843). This in spite of the fact that Hegel was an avid, indeed
"religious," imbiber of current events. As Hegel wrote in this period,
"Reading the newspaper in early morning is a kind of realistic morning
prayer."
Why can't intellectuals fathom the impact on Hegel of the Haitian
Revolution--a then unprecedented extension of the idea of freedom to an
historical struggle of actual slaves? Buck-Morss' answer is that "the
intellectual historians of German philosophy know only one place to look
for the answer: the writings of other intellectuals" (p. 843).
Unfortunately, Buck-Morss lumps Marx together with "(white) Marxists" who
helped to bury the concreteness of the master/slave narrative because they
focused on class struggle. She writes, "Since the 1840s, with the early
writings of Karl Marx, the struggle between the master and slave has been
abstracted from literal reference and read once again as a metaphor--this
time for the class struggle" (p. 850). She fails to see that for Marx, not
only was literal slavery integral to capitalism's globalization and
explosion of wealth, but the struggle against slavery became the pivot
around which modern freedom could unfold. As I put it in my talk:
"We talk a lot about the need to oppose the globalization of capitalism
today, but it was Marx who made clear that capitalism's first moment of
globalization was built on slavery. He saw as well the centrality of the
slave revolts and Black regiments in the American Civil War to get to a new
freedom. On Dec. 26, 1846 Marx wrote to Pavel Annenkov that 'Direct slavery
is thepivot of our industrialism today as much as machinery, credit, etc.
Without slavery, you have no cotton, without cotton you have no modern
industry. It is slavery that has given value to the colonies; it was the
colonies that created world trade; it is world trade that is the necessary
condition for large-scale machine industry. Also, before the slave-trade in
Negroes, the colonies supplied the Old World with but very few products and
did not visibly change the face of the earth. Slavery is thus an economic
category of the highest importance.'"
It was Raya Dunayevskaya who saw, in the actual opposition to slavery, the
indigenous roots of Marxism in America (see MARXISM AND FREEDOM). Her
AMERICAN CIVILIZATION ON TRIAL (1963) traces the self-development of the
idea of freedom in U.S. history in which the Black masses have been
vanguard. Black masses have continuously exposed the hollowness of the
pompous, abstract proclamations of democratic ideals as they fought for
genuine democracy and freedom in the face of actual oppression in the form
of slavery and racism.
Buck-Morss rightly takes to task the academic world's lack of a genuine
objective scholarship which appreciates the objectivity of "subjective"
mass struggles, that is, that the "spirit of liberty...could be catching,
crossing the line not only between races but between slaves and freemen."
(p. 845) For her, grasping this has "potential for rescuing the idea of
universal human history from the uses to which white domination has put
it...the project of universal freedom does not need to be discarded but
rather, redeemed and reconstituted on a different basis" (p. 863).
Hegel intended that his articulation of the "catchiness" of the idea of
freedom, which he called the self-determination of the Idea, would aid in
the realization of "universal freedom." Today's liberation theorists and
activists would do well to take another look at Dunayevskaya's body of
work, built on the development of the idea of freedom in masses in motion.
For Dunayevskaya this was a way to "unchain" Hegel's dialectic of the Idea
of "universal freedom," which could itself become a force for coalescence
and the realization of new forms of social solidarity among different
subjects struggling for freedom and a new society.
|
subscribe to news and letters newspaper. 10 issues per year delivered to you for $5.00/year.
|
